Navigation
  1. Home »
  2. Restaurants »
  3. Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery Menu Prices

Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery Menu Prices

Verified Prices
Menu-Prices is not associated with Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery
Jump to Section Show
You are viewing Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery prices confirmed by Menu-Prices at the following location:
126 Rivington St, New York, NY 10002 US (212) 995-1960
Prices shown in: USD

Top Menu Items

Sunshine Cupcake
$3.25
-
Bob Cupcake
$3.25
-
Pumpkin Cupcake
$3.25
-
Lemon Yummy Cupcake
$3.25
-
Banana Pudding
$3.00
-
Chocolate Chip Deliciousness
Layers of home made chocolate chip cookies, butterscotch pudding and whip cream.
$3.00
-
Chocolate Bomb
Layers of home made dark chocolate cake, chocolate pudding and chocolate whip cream.
$3.00
-

Thanksgiving Pies

PRE-ORDER ONLY - 9" Pumpkin Pie
**THIS PIE NEEDS A 24 HOUR PRE-ORDER WINDOW** Classic Pumpkin Pie that is just how you love it - nothin' fancy, just home made and good.
$35.00
-
PRE-ORDER ONLY - 9" Double Crusted Apple Pie
**THIS PIE NEEDS A 24 HOUR PRE-ORDER WINDOW** Fresh apples baked and topped with home made crust. Classic pie anytime of the year.
$35.00
-
PRE-ORDER ONLY - 9" Blueberry Crispy Crumble
**THIS PIE NEEDS A 24 HOUR PRE-ORDER WINDOW** Good ol' fashioned blueberry pie with just the right amount of sweet and a crispy baked crumble top.
$35.00
-
PRE-ORDER ONLY - 9" Pecan Pie
**THIS PIE NEEDS A 24 HOUR PRE-ORDER WINDOW** This Southern Pecan Pie won’t let you down. Rich but not too sweet.
$35.00
-
PRE-ORDER - 9” Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
**THIS PIE NEEDS A 24 HOUR PRE-ORDER WINDOW** This home made Strawberry Rhubarb pie is sure to make your mouth pucker with sweetness. Most popular pie.
$25.00
-
PRE-ORDER ONLY - 9" Coconut Cream Pie
**THIS PIE NEEDS A 24 HOUR PRE-ORDER WINDOW** A creamy coconut-y custard pie with fresh whipped cream. Rich and decadent, but not overly sweet!
$40.00
-
PRE-ORDER ONLY - 9" Peanut Butter Ice Box Pie
**THIS PIE NEEDS A 24 HOUR PRE-ORDER WINDOW** Dunno if you remember Clark Bars from when you were a kid? Maybe I'm dating myself here, but this is reminiscent of the peanut butter nougat in that candy bar. If that reference doesn't mean anything to you, I'd say it's like a thick peanut butter mousse sitting cozily on a graham cracker crust
$40.00
-

The Cast Cupcakes

S'mores Cupcake-NEW FLAVOR
Chocolate cupcake with merengue, graham cracker cookie bottom, marshmallow and a drizzle of chocolate ganache. Good with or without a fire.
$3.50
-
Sunshine Cupcake (The Cast Cupcakes)
Classic yellow cake with vanilla buttercream. Icing color and sprinkles may vary.
$3.25
-
Black and White Just Right Cupcake
Dark chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream. Icing color and sprinkles may vary.
$3.25
-
Bob Cupcake (The Cast Cupcakes)
Yellow cake with chocolate almond buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.25
-
Ooey Gooey Cupcake
Dark chocolate cake with chocolate almond buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.25
-
Sexy Red Velvet Cupcake
Red velvet cake with satin buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.25
-
Sassy Red Velvet Cupcake
Red velvet cake with chocolate almond buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.25
-
Pistachio Cupcake
Pistachio cake with satin buttercream with a pistachio on top.
$3.25
-
Pumpkin Cupcake (The Cast Cupcakes)
Pumpkin cake with cream cheese icing with a walnut on top.
$3.25
-
Oreo Cookie Cupcake
Oreo cupcake with satin buttercream with cookie crumble on top.
$3.25
-
Lemon Yummy Cupcake (The Cast Cupcakes)
Lemon cake with lemon buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.25
-
Faux-conut Cupcake
Yellow cake with satin buttercream and coconut shreds.
$3.25
-
Goodie Goodie Cupcake
Dark chocolate cake with whipped peanut butter buttercream. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.25
-
Strawberry Cupcake with Cream Cheese
Strawberry cake with cream cheese icing. Also known as The Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake. Sprinkles may vary.
$3.25
-
Strawberry Peanut Butter Cupcake
Bits of Strawberry baked into this cupcake with a Whipped Peanut Butter Icing. Also known as the "Pinch Me Cupcake". Sprinkles may vary.
$3.25
-

The Pudding Posse

Banana Pudding (The Pudding Posse)
Layers of creamy vanilla pudding, nilla wafers and bananas.
$3.00
-
Chocolate Chip Deliciousness (The Pudding Posse)
Layers of home made chocolate chip cookies, butterscotch pudding and whip cream.
$3.00
-
Chocolate Bomb (The Pudding Posse)
Layers of home made dark chocolate cake, chocolate pudding and chocolate whip cream.
$3.00
-
Strawberry Lemon Trifle
Layers of our lemon cake, frozen strawberries and whip cream.
$3.00
-
Schmapple Pudding
Layers of our classic yellow cake, sliced apples, layers of vanilla pudding, caramel whip cream and walnuts.
$3.00
-
The Coffee Java Xpress
Layers of our coffee cake, coffee pudding and coffee whip cream.
$3.00
-
Awesome Peanut Butter Chocolate Pudding
Layers of home made peanut butter cookies, whipped peanut butter cream and peanut butter whip cream.
$3.00
-
Sexy Red Velvet Pudding
Layers of red velvet cake, vanilla pudding, whipped sweetened cream cheese whip cream and pecans.
$3.00
-
The Nog
Super moist pumpkin cake with our secret eggnog pudding, whip cream and a dash of nutmeg.
$3.00
-
Mint Chocolate Chip Pudding
Made our own mint chocolate chip cookies, layer it with vanilla pudding and mint whip cream.
$3.00
-

Cheesecake

Plain Cheesecake
Simple cheesecake with a nilla wafer bottom.
$3.25
-
Chocolate Chippie Cheesecake
Who doesn't like some chocolate with their cheesecake. Add in some mini chocolate chips and its a score of yumminess! Oh, don't forget the nilla wafer bottom.
$3.25
-
Slice New York Cheesecake
Good old fashion NY Cheesecake with a classic graham cracker crust.
$6.00
-

Assorted Bars

Oooh Brownies
Espresso chocolate brownie. Rich, rich and rich.
$4.00
-
Yum-yum Bars
Shortbread crust layered with semi-sweet chocolate chips, raspberry preserves with a shortbread, chocolate chip crumble. Contains Walnuts.
$4.00
-

Hot Out of the Oven Cookies

Sexy Red Velvet Cookies
These cookies have a rich cocoa taste that make them sexy on the palate.
$0.85
-
Chocolate Chip Cookie
This is that no frills, oversized, over chipped chocolate chip cookie.
$0.85
-
Iced Sugar Cookies
Classic butter cookie with buttercream and sprinkles. Sprinkles may vary.
$1.75
-
Sugar Cookie
Classic buttery sugary cookie.
$0.85
-
Mint Chocolate Chip Cookie
Mint chocolate cookies like those classic thin mint cookies, only better.
$0.85
-

Mini Pies/By the Slice

4.5" Mini Pumpkin Pie
Classic Pumpkin Pie that is just how you love it - nothin' fancy.
$6.50
-
4.5" Mini Double Crusted Apple Pie
Fresh apples baked and topped with home made crust. Just the right size for you.
$6.50
-
4.5" Mini Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Explosion of strawberries and the tangy tartness of the rhubarb that comes with that first bite topped with an oat crumble.
$6.50
-
Slice of Peanut Butter Icebox Pie
If you like Peanut Butter this is the pie for you. Baked Graham Cracker Crust filled with Whipped Peanut Butter. Decadent!!!
$7.00
-

Other Treats

Slice of Pistachio Bundt Cake
This amazing pistachio bundt cake is delicious in its simplicity.
$4.85
-
Slice of Coffee Cake
This classic coffee cake with cinnamon and walnuts baked in with a sugary walnut top. Was rated as one of New York's best coffee cakes.
$4.85
-
Slice of Apple Bundt Cake
This staff favorite has chunks of apple baked in.
$4.85
-
Tres leche
Our classic Tres leche with rum! (Contains alcohol.)
$7.00
-
Flan
Spanish custard with caramel sauce.
$5.75
-
Marble Bundt
If you like this and that. Then this Marble Bundt cake is right up your alley. A lovely swirl of both vanilla and chocolate cake. Get it before the staff gobbles it up. Perfect afternoon treat with that cup of coffee.
$4.00
-

Vegan Treats!

Vegan Chocolate Chocolate Chip Bundt Slice
100% Vegan Rich and Decadent Chocolate Chocolate Chip Bundt. Simple and totally rich and chocolately! Dusting of confectioners sugar tops it off!
$4.85
-
Vegan Sunshine Vanilla with Vanilla
Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream. 100% vegan.
$3.75
-
Vegan Chocolate Explosion Cupcake
Vegan Chocolate cake with Vegan Chocolate Buttercream. So decadent! 100% Vegan
$3.75
-
Vegan French Toast cupcake
Vanilla cupcake with a cinnamon and nutmeg spiced vanilla buttercream. 100% vegan!
$3.75
-
Vegan Black & White
Dark Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream. 100% vegan and still a classic.
$3.75
-

Mini Cupcakes

Mini Sunshine Cupcakes
Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream in assorted colors (pink, yellow, green & blue) with sprinkles. Pack of 12. Sprinkle choice may vary.
$18.00
-
Mini Black & White Cupcakes
Dark chocolate cake with various colored buttercream and sprinkles. Pack of 12. Sprinkle choice may vary.
$18.00
-
Mini Sexy Red Velvet Cupcakes
Sexy Red Velvet cake with Satin Buttercream (Pack of 12). Lighter buttercream. Sprinkles choice may vary.
$18.00
-
Disclaimer: Menu-Prices gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.

Search

Close