Navigation
  1. Home »
  2. Restaurants »
  3. Sugar Box NYC Menu Prices

Sugar Box NYC Menu Prices

Verified Prices
Menu-Prices is not associated with Sugar Box NYC
Jump to Section Show
You are viewing Sugar Box NYC prices confirmed by Menu-Prices at one or more locations in United States
Prices shown in: USD

Picked For You

Oddfellows Oatmeal Cookie Dough
Eggs, milk, and wheat.
$12.95
-
McConnell's Banana and Salted Caramel
Ripe bananas, pureed and folded into central coast milk and cream, then mated to thick, salt spiked, and salted caramel sauce.
$14.95
-
Moose Tracks
Moose tracks fudge swirl and peanut butter mini cups in smooth vanilla ice cream.
$13.95
-
Ben and Jerry's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Vanilla ice cream with gobs of cookie dough.
$7.99
-
McConnell's Double Peanut Butter Chip Ice Cream
Central coast, grass fed milk, and cream meet savory, salty nuttiness in this especially well balanced blend of rich, creamy, salty peanut butter folded into smooth and indulgent peanut butter ice cream. Includes copious amounts of bittersweet chocolate.
$14.95
-

Recommended

Cakes

Blackout Chocolate Cake
Chocolate cake with creamy old fashioned dark chocolate pudding. Wrapped with chocolate pudding and fresh chocolate cake crumbs.
$6.95
-
Chocolate Cake
Moist chocolate cake filled with dark chocolate frosting and decorated with chocolate flakes.
$6.95
-
Chocolate Nonpareil Cake
Chocolate cake with pastel buttercream and nonpareil candy.
$6.95
-
Oreo and Cream
Chocolate cake is topped and filled with rich vanilla buttercream and crunchy bits of oreo cookies, finished off with an oreo crumb layer around the side.
$6.95
-
Sprinkle Vanilla Cake
Vanilla cake with pastel buttercream with rainbow sprinkles.
$6.95
-
Sprinkle Vanilla Cake (Cakes)
Vanilla cake with pastel buttercream with rainbow sprinkles.
$6.95
-
Birthday Cake Batter Bites
Half lbs. Milk, wheat, and soy.
$8.00
-
Brownie Cupcake
Chocolate cake with chocolate fudge icing and yummy brownie chunks, drizzled with milk and white chocolate sauce.
$3.95
-
Snickers Cupcake
Vanilla cake with buttermilk icing and dipped into chunks of snicker pieces.
$3.95
-
Apple Pie Cupcake
Fall flavor. Vanilla cake filled with an apple compote, topped with sweet cinnamon cream cheese frosting, caramel drizzle, and apple pie crumbs.
$3.95
-
Carrot Cup Cake
Sweet cream cheese icing, surrounded by toasted coconut flakes and walnuts.
$3.95
-
Cookie Dough Cupcake
Vanilla cake, topped with a scoop of cookie dough, (raw and eggless), large chunks of blondies, and chocolate drizzle.
$3.95
-
Oreo Cupcake
Chocolate cake with oreo buttercream icing. Dipping in oreo crushed chunks.
$3.95
-
Red Velvet Cupcake
Rich moist chocolate cake with sweet cream cheese frosting.
$3.95
-

Fresh Cookies

Double Chocolate Chip Cookie
Fresh baked. Double chocolate chip.
$1.95
-
Double Chocolate Chip Cookie (Fresh Cookies)
Fresh baked. Double chocolate chip.
$1.95
-
Sugar Cookie
Fresh baked daily. Sugar cookies.
$1.95
-

Brownie Bars

Chocolate Brownie Fudge Bar
Fudge brownie with shaved dark chocolate as topping.
$4.95
-
Caramel Nut Bar
Wheats, eggs, milk, peanuts, and soy. Rich squares with caramel and chocolate chip.
$4.95
-
Oreo Cookie Bar
Classic Oreo cookies bar. Milk, eggs, wheat, and soy.
$4.95
-
Lemon Bar
Kosher. Lemon jam.
$4.95
-

Milk Shakes

Cotton Candy Ice Cream Shake
New. Pink and blue cotton candy flavor.
$9.00
-
Chocolate Lover's Chocolate Shake
Giffords rich chocolate ice cream with chocolate cake crunch, chocolate truffles, and fudge ripples.
$9.00
-
Cake Batter Shake
Yellow cake batter ice cream with chocolate frosting and shortcake chunks.
$9.00
-
Cookie Dough Cake Batter Shake
Giffords vanilla ice cream with chocolate chips and cookie dough.
$9.00
-
Cookie Dough Cake Batter Shake (Milk Shakes)
Giffords vanilla ice cream with chocolate chips and cookie dough.
$9.00
-
Sea Salt Caramel Truffle Shake
Giffords vanilla ice cream sea salt caramel truffle.
$9.00
-
Sea Salt Caramel Truffle Shake (Milk Shakes)
Giffords vanilla ice cream sea salt caramel truffle.
$9.00
-
Double Cookies and Cream Shake
Giffords cookies in cream in vanilla ice cream.
$9.00
-
Green Mint Chip
16 oz. Green mint chip ice cream.
$9.00
-

Ice Cream Sandwich

Milk Cult Vegan Avocado Ice Cream Sandwich
Milk cult, vegan, and coconut milk. Avocado ice cream with chocolate wafer.
$4.50
-
Milk Cult Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich
Milk cult. Vanilla ice cream with chocolate chip cookie sandwich.
$4.50
-
Italian Bomba Gelato Cannoball Ice Cream Sandwich
A scoop of classic vanilla and chocolate gelato separated by a cherry and sliced almonds covered in cinnamon and finished with a chocolate coating. Individual servings.
$5.95
-
Hazelnut Truffle Bomba Ice Cream Sandwich
Hazelnuts semifreddo ice cream with a liquid chocolate core, coated with praline hazelnuts, and crushed meringue. Individual serving.
$5.95
-
Exotic Bomba Ice Cream Sandwich
Mango, passion fruit, raspberry sorbetto, white chocolate, and drizzled with chocolate. Individual serving.
$5.95
-

Vegan Dairy Free Ice Cream

Jeni's Texas Sheet Cake Non Dairy Frozen Dessert
Decadent chocolate cake crumbles, bittersweet fudge, and palate gripping cocoa. Big, bold, and beautiful.
$16.95
-
Jeni's Frose Sorbet
Sangria style frozen rose with pear, strawberry, and watermelon. Refreshing and bright with a tinge of tartness.
$15.00
-
Van Leeuwan Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Vegan and gluten free.
$13.00
-
Little Baby’s Chocolate Salt Malt Vegan Ice Cream
Non dairy. Coconut cream kosher salt.
$13.00
-
Van Leuween Vegan Dark Chocolate
Vegan.
$13.00
-
Little Baby’s Lychee Lemonade Vegan Ice Cream
Non dairy. Sweet and tart combination of lychee and lemonade.
$13.00
-
Van Leeuwan Vegan Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Vegan peanut butter.
$13.00
-
Little Baby’s Speculos Vegan Ice Cream
Speculos coconut cream base made to taste like a cookies and cream ice cream.
$13.00
-
Jeni's Dark Chocolate Truffle
Dairy free and vegan.
$16.95
-
Mcconnell's Turkish Coffee Vegan
Coconut milk and gluten free.
$13.00
-
Mcconnell's Eureka Lemon and Marionberries Vegan
Dairy free, gluten free, and coconut.
$13.00
-
Little Baby’s Vanilla Coconut Clove
Coconut cream. Non dairy.
$13.00
-
Mcconnell's Toasted Coconut Almond Chip Vegan
Dairy free, gluten free, coconuts, and almonds.
$13.00
-

Little Baby's Ice Cream

Little Baby’s Vanilla Cardamom Cream
Vanilla with cardamom.
$11.00
-
Little Baby’s Cinnamon Clove Ice Cream
A cinnamon ice cream with dashes of liquid smoke, brown sugar, and chipotle.
$11.00
-
Little Baby's Chocolate Salt Malt Ice Cream
$11.00
-

Jeni's Ice Cream

Boston Cream Pie Ice Cream
A salted vanilla custard layered with yellow cake pieces and darkest chocolate fudge.
$16.95
-
Blackout Chocolate Cake Ice Cream
A chocolate ice cream quadruple threat with cake, extra bitter fudge, and chocolate pieces.
$16.95
-
Lemon and Blueberries Parfait Ice Cream
Tart and uber creamy lemon with from scratch blueberry jam in fresh cultured buttermilk and cream.
$16.95
-
Fluffernutter Pie Ice Cream
Roasted peanut butter and vanilla marshmallow ice creams side by side with oat pie crust pieces.
$16.95
-
Savannah Buttermint Ice Cream
A buttery after dinner mint ice cream with white chocolate flecks.
$16.95
+13.00%
Sweet Cream Biscuits Peach and Jam Ice Cream
Buttermilk ice cream, crumbled biscuits, and swirls of jam made with Georgia peaches from the peach truck.
$16.95
+13.00%
Brandied Banana Brulee Ice Cream
Banana custard with small batch brandy, caramel sauce, and burnt sugar candies.
$16.95
-
Goat Cheese with Red Cherries
$16.95
-
Jenis Cream Puff Ice Cream
Salty and vanilla custard ice cream freckled with toasty puff pastry flakes.
$16.95
-
Jenis Brambleberry Crisp Ice Cream
Oven toasted oat streusel and a sweet tart brambleberry jam of blackberries and blackcurrants layered throughout vanilla ice cream.
$16.95
-
Jeni's Green Mint Chip
Peppermint cream colored with spirulina, crunchy, and direct trade chocolate from askinosie in Missouri.
$16.95
-
Jeni's Popcorn Peanuts
Heirloom popcorn ice cream with notes of butter and honey. Sweet and salty caramel peanuts.
$15.00
-
Jenis Milkiest Chocolate Ice Cream
Creamy milk chocolate mixed with evaporated milk, ohio wildflower honey, and grass grazed milk. Evaporated milk gives this ice cream lots of milkiness and a delightful chewiness.
$16.95
-

Oddfellows Ice Cream

Oddfellows Banana Puddin
Eggs, milk, and wheat.
$12.95
+17.73%
Oddfellows Burnt Marshmallow
$12.95
+17.73%
Oddfellows Dark Chocolate Chunk
$12.95
+17.73%
Oddfellows Oatmeal Cookie Dough (Oddfellows Ice Cream)
Eggs, milk, and wheat.
$12.95
-

Ben and Jerrys Ice Cream

Gimme Smores Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Toasted marshmallow ice cream, fudge chunks, and graham crackers.
$7.99
-
Red Velvet Cake Ice Cream
Red velvet cake ice cream with red velvet cake pieces and cream cheese frosting swirl.
$7.99
-
Banana Split
Banana and strawberry ice cream with walnuts, fudge chunks, and fudge swirls.
$7.99
-
Americone Dream Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Vanilla ice cream, fudge covered waffle cone pieces, and caramel swirl.
$7.99
-
Brownie Batter Core
Chocolate and vanilla ice creams with fudge brownies and brownie batter core.
$7.99
-
Cherry Garcia
The cherry Garcia from ben and jerrys.
$7.99
-
Ben and Jerry's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough (Ben and Jerrys Ice Cream)
Vanilla ice cream with gobs of cookie dough.
$7.99
-
Chunky Monkey Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Banana ice cream with fudge chunks and walnuts.
$7.99
-
Chubby Hubby Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Vanilla fudge ice cream, peanutty fudge covered pretzels, and peanut buttery swirls.
$7.99
-
Half Baked Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Chocolate vanilla ice cream with chocolate cookie dough and fudge brownie.
$7.99
-
Milk and Cookies Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Vanilla ice cream with a chocolate cookie swirl, chocolate chip, and chocolate chip cookies.
$7.99
-
New York Super Fudge Chunk Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Chocolate ice cream, white and dark fudge chunks, pecans, walnuts and fudge covered almonds.
$7.99
-
Strawberry Cheesecake Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Strawberry cheesecake ice cream with strawberries and a thick graham cracker swirl.
$7.99
-
The Tonight Dough Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Caramel and chocolate ice cream, chocolate chip cookie dough and peanut butter cookie dough.
$7.99
-
Cinnamom Bun Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Caramel ice cream, cinnamon bun dough and cinnamon streusel swirl.
$7.99
-
Phish Food Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Chocolate ice cream, gooey marshmallow swirls, caramel swirls, and fudge fish.
$7.99
-
Vanilla Caramel Fudge Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
Vanilla ice cream with caramel fudge.
$7.99
-

Ample Hills Ice Cream

Ample Hills Chocolate Milk and Cookies Ice Cream
Chocolate milk ice cream with pieces of all natural back to nature sandwich creme cookies.
$12.00
-

Giffords Famous Ice Cream Quarts

Maine Lobster Tracks
Vanilla ice cream, lobster colored chocolate cups filled with caramel all swirled with a unique eclair crunch.
$13.95
+16.25%
Moose Tracks (Giffords Famous Ice Cream Quarts)
Moose tracks fudge swirl and peanut butter mini cups in smooth vanilla ice cream.
$13.95
-
Chocolate Brownie Crunch
Fudgy brownie chunks dunked in light chocolate ice cream swirled with the chocolate coated cookie crunch.
$13.95
+16.25%

McConnells Ice Cream

McConnell's Banana and Salted Caramel (McConnells Ice Cream)
Ripe bananas, pureed and folded into central coast milk and cream, then mated to thick, salt spiked, and salted caramel sauce.
$14.95
-
McConnell's Chocolate Covered Strawberries Ice Cream
The richly complex, insanely smooth creaminess of central coast, grass fed milk, and cream, cage free organic eggs and pure cane sugar meet its decadent match in Guittard bittersweet, melted chocolate and perfectly ripe, Santa Barbara strawberries.
$14.95
+24.58%
McConnell's Cookies and Cream
Decadent, dense and velvety smooth, sweet cream ice cream, paired with rich, and chewy chocolate cookies.
$14.95
+24.58%
McConnell's Double Peanut Butter Chip Ice Cream (McConnells Ice Cream)
Central coast, grass fed milk, and cream meet savory, salty nuttiness in this especially well balanced blend of rich, creamy, salty peanut butter folded into smooth and indulgent peanut butter ice cream. Includes copious amounts of bittersweet chocolate.
$14.95
-
McConnell's Eureka Lemon and Marionberries Ice Cream
Glorious, picked at their prime Oregon marionberries, cooked to a jammy perfection and folded into tart and tangy, eureka lemon infused California central coast, grass fed milk, and cream.
$14.95
+24.58%
McConnell's Sea Salt Cream and Cookies Ice Cream
Dense, velvety smooth and creamy, sweet cream ice cream, a hint of local sea salt and bountiful bits of our chewy, Guittard chocolate chunk cookies.
$14.95
+24.58%
McConnell's Toasted Coconut Almond Chip Ice Cream
Shredded coconut, toasted to caramelized perfection, crunchy, salt roasted almonds and signature, Guittard bittersweet, melted chocolate chip, mated to fresh, California central coast, grass fed milk and cream.
$14.95
+24.58%
McConnell's Salted Caramel Chip Ice Cream
A uniquely deep and complex salted caramel. Almost toffee like in flavor brought together with a stunningly rich mix of cage free organic eggs, pure cane sugar and fresh, central coast, grass fed milk, and cream, then topped off by signature, Guittard bittersweet and melted chocolate.
$14.95
+24.58%
McConnell's Turkish Coffee Ice Cream
A Three bean selection of espresso and cold processed coffees delivers all the aroma, smoothness and complex coffee flavor, leaving behind any acidity and bitterness. A true coffee fanatics ice cream.
$14.95
+24.58%

Van Leeuwans Ice Cream

Van Leeuwan Cookies and Cream Ice Cream
Pint.
$12.95
+29.50%
Van Leeuwen's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Pint.
$12.95
+29.50%

Gummy Sours

Sour Mix Gummy Candy
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Toxic Waste Super Sour Gummy Bears
Insanely sour.
$7.00
-
Mini Gummy Sour Sharks
Sour blue sharks. Haribo.
$7.00
-
Sour Watermelon Gummy Bears
$7.00
-
Sour Power Green Apple Candy Belts
Sour apple flavored gummy candy belts. Quarter lb.
$4.00
-
Sour Power Berry Blue Candy Belts
Sour blue raspberry gummy belts. Quarter lb.
$4.00
-
Sour Power Quattro Belts
Sour rainbow. Quarter lb.
$4.00
-
Sour Power Strawberry Belts
Sour strawberry candy belts gummy. Quarter lb.
$4.00
-
Gimbal's Sour Lips
Half lbs. Kosher, gluten free, soy free, and egg free.
$7.00
-
Pink Skulls Swedish
Half lb. Sour marshmallow skull with raspberry flavor. No gelatin. No corn syrup.
$7.00
-
Sour Swedish Skulls
Half lb.
$7.00
-
Sour Skulls Mix
Half lb. No corn syrup.
$7.00
-
Sour Peach Lips
Half lb.
$7.00
-
Mixed Sour Lips
Half lb.
$7.00
-
Sour Apple Wrenches
Half lbs. Sugar coated.
$7.00
-
Sours Tongues
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Gummy Chicken Feet Candy
Half lbs. Cherry flavored.
$7.00
-
Gummy Red Hot Chilli Peppers Candy
Half lbs. Hot and spicy.
$7.00
-
Sour Gummy Twin Cherries Candy
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Sour Gummy Bottles
Half lbs. Blue raspberry flavored. Sugar coated.
$7.00
-
Sugar Coated Sour Strawberry Gummy Swedish
Half lbs. Sour strawberry sugar coated. Gelatin free. No corn syrup.
$7.00
-
Gummy Sour Creepy Giant Spiders
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Sour Cola Bottles
Half lbs. Coke flavored. Sugar coated.
$7.00
-
Sour Strawberry Wrenches
Half lbs. Sugar coated.
$7.00
-

Gummy Sweets

Sweet Mix Gummy Candy
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Sweet Wild Berry Red Licorice Gummy
Half lb. Swedish. No GMO. No corn syrup. No trans fat.
$7.00
-
Broadway Strawberry Wheels (Gummy Sweets)
Half lb. Strawberry flavor.
$7.00
-
Broadway Strawberry Wheels
Half lb. Strawberry flavor.
$7.00
-
Assorted Sweet Gummy Robots
Half lbs. Fruit flavored gummy robot shaped.
$7.00
-
Gummy Bears Bubbly Champagne
Half lbs. Champagne flavor.
$7.00
-
Sugar Love Swedish Hearts
Half lbs. Sugar coated red gummy hearts. No gelatin. No corn syrup.
$7.00
-
Strawberry Gummy Swedish
Half lbs. Tangy strawberry is gummy. No gelatin. No corn syrup.
$7.00
-
Sweet Lips Gummy Swedish
Half lbs. Strawberry flavored gummy shaped in lips. No high fructose corn syrup. Gelatin free.
$7.00
-
Rambo Melon Swedish
Half lbs. Sour melon logs.
$7.00
-
Exotic Fruit Mix Gummy Candy With Fruit Flavors
Half lbs. Assorted flavors.
$7.00
-
Mini Gummy Sharks
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Twelve Flavor Gummi Bears
Half lbs. Fat free, gluten free.
$7.00
-
Gummy Worms Candy
Half lbs. Gluten free.
$7.00
-
Gummy Ice Cream Cones Candy
Half lbs. Vanilla, strawberry, raspberry and mint chocolate chip flavors.
$7.00
-
Gummy Brains Candy
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Gummy Teeth Candy
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Gummy Dinosaurs Haribo Candy
Half lbs. Banana, black currant, mango, melon, and strawberry flavors.
$7.00
-
Sweet Cola Bottles Haribo
Half pound. Large size cola bottles
$7.00
-
Sweet Gummy Twin Cherries
Haribo.
$7.00
-

Taffy

Pomegranate Taffy
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Blueberry Taffy
Half lbs. Blueberry flavored.
$7.00
-
Blue Raspberry Salt Water Taffy
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Chilli Mango Madness Taffy
Half lbs. Served with sweet and heat.
$7.00
-
Cotton Candy Taffy
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Green Apple Taffy
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Orange Salt Water Taffy
Half lbs.
$7.00
-
Watermelon Taffy
Half lbs. Pink and green watermellon taffy.
$7.00
-

Gifts

Giant Smarties in a Tin
Gluten free and vegan.
$10.99
-
Disclaimer: Menu-Prices gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.

Search

Close