Navigation
  1. Home »
  2. Restaurants »
  3. Matey's Restaurant Menu Prices

Matey's Restaurant Menu Prices

Verified Prices
Menu-Prices is not associated with Matey's Restaurant
Jump to Section Show
You are viewing Matey's Restaurant prices confirmed by Menu-Prices at the following location:
110 Franklin St, Michigan City, IN 46360 US (219) 872-9471
Prices shown in: USD

Top Menu Items

Chicken Tenders Basket
Choice of ranch, BBQ or honey mustard for dipping.
$14.75
-
Crabcake Sandwich
Our famous recipe, topped with homemade crab louie sauce.
$14.75
-

Sharables

Nachos
A large plate of tortilla chips with seasoned ground beef, salsa, cheese and fresh toppings and drizzled with sour cream and cilantro pesto. Substitute chicken for an additional charge.
$14.75
-
Fried Mushrooms
A true favorite just hit our menu. Perfectly sized mushroom caps meet the deep fryer and are served with our Jalapeno Ranch.
$9.99
-
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with marinara sauce.
$9.99
-
Jumbo Chicken Wings
A pile of our famous chicken wings or boneless wings. Served with your choice of sauce.
$17.25
-
Deep Fried Pickles
Served with ranch dipping sauce.
$9.99
-
Pretzel Bites
Served warm with our signature cheese dipping sauce.
$9.99
-
Basket of Fries
$7.50
-
Basket of Onion Rings
$8.50
-
Buffalo Shrimp
Five of our own Jumbo Shrimp, seasoned, breaded and fried until it's golden brown and delicious! Sauced in our signature buffalo sauce and accompanied by your choice of ranch or blue cheese.
$17.25
-
Quesadilla
The classic version but Matey's sized. Cheese, onion, and tomato is standard form.
$9.99
-
Lobster Nachos
You won't have a problem finding the lobster atop the pile of fresh fried tortillas. Topped with our cheddar sauce, cilantro pesto drizzle, and a touch of zesty sirracha to balance this superstar appetizer.
$17.25
-
Matey's Sample Platter
A little bit of all the favorites, Chicken Wings, Onion Rings, Extremers, Deep Fried Pickles and cheese sticks. No substitutions please.
$19.75
-
Jumbo Chicken Wings OR Boneless Wings
Matey's doesn't skimp on this full 1 lb. order. Fresh (never frozen) oversized wings would put Buffalo, NY on its toes. Perfectly crispy, served with celery, your choice of signature sauces and ranch or blue cheese to complete your wing experience.
$17.25
-
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
We know you've ordered Jumbo Shrimp before and thought WT# when they arrived at your table looking anything but JUMBO - not at Matey's - these tiger shrimp are appropriately named. Cooked just right. Served with cocktail sauce and a lemon wedge. Do we get extra points by presentation?
$16.75
-
Oysters Rockefeller
Does this big blue and yellow building really house the most amazing Oyster Rock you've ever tried? YES IT DOES! We were skeptical at first ourselves but having tried them all over the world - these are hands down the best! Put us to the test but be warned, you will be hooked. Our signature-blend of spinach, bacon, oysters and a few other items we keep to ourselves. Served 6 per order. Allow additional time.
$18.50
-
Shrimp and Crab Extremers
An amazing shrimp and crab popper with a mild jalapeno kick.
$12.25
-

Fresh Greens & Soups

Garden Salad
Greens, tomato, cucumber and shredded cheese.
$8.75
-
Taco Salad
Oversized taco bowl made to order then filled with mixed greens topped with our seasoned ground beef, olives, tomatoes, onions, and shredded cheese. Served with sour cream and tangy salsa.
$15.99
-
Almost World Famous Cajun Chowder
$4.99
-
Fuji Apple Salad
Grilled chicken breast, fresh Fuji apples, toasted walnuts, blue cheese crumbles, tomatoes, red onions, with our homemade Apple Dijon dressing, atop crispy mixed greens.
$18.50
-
Summer Strawberry Salad
Sweet strawberries, walnuts, fresh mozzarella, a touch of basil on our mixed greens with tangy balsamic dressing.
$17.25
-

Baskets

Coconut Shrimp Basket
Served with sweet and sour sauce.
$14.75
-
Chicken Tenders Basket (Baskets)
Choice of ranch, BBQ or honey mustard for dipping.
$14.75
-
Breaded Shrimp Basket
Breaded and fried with cocktail sauce.
$14.75
-
Fish and Chips Basket
Guinness battered cod served with house made tartar sauce.
$14.75
-

Handhelds

Matey Burger
1/2 lb of beef served deluxe with American cheese and mayo.
$12.25
-
Prime Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Shaved prime rib takes this classic up more than 1 notch! Topped with mushrooms, onions, peppers, and of course lots of cheese.
$17.25
-
Crabcake Sandwich (Handhelds)
Our famous recipe, topped with homemade crab louie sauce.
$14.75
-
Peppercorn Burger
A must try! 1/2 lb Burger with our signature peppercorn cream sauce, rich gouda cheese and crispy bacon
$15.99
-
Ultimate Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Served with lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo. Add cheese for an additional charge.
$10.99
-
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Can't miss with sauteed mushroom and Swiss cheese
$14.75
-
Drunken Fish Tacos
Beer battered cod cradles in flour tortillas with shredded cheese and our louie sauce.
$15.99
-
Italian Beef
A Chicago tradition perfected here, thinly shaved slow-roasted beef with spicy giardinera on a French baguette
$13.50
-
Fried Perch Sandwich
Matey's signature beer batter perch made sandwich style. The classic has maintained its menu position for over 25 years.
$17.25
-
The First Mate
Slow roasted prime rib, shaved very thin, on a Kaiser roll, with au jus and our homemade horseradish sauce.
$14.75
-
Blackened Walleye Sandwich
Fresh Great Lakes walleye blackened and served with tartar on a French roll, with fries and slaw.
$19.50
-
Soft Shell Crab Sandwich
Hand dredged, beer battered and crispy fried soft shell crab with our zesty Louis sauce, with fries and slaw.
$17.25
-
Lobster Roll
From the East Coast to your plate right here at Matey's. Fresh sourced Maine Lobster lightly sauced and seasoned to pay homage to this classic. The lobster is the star! Served on a brioche New England lobster roll with fries and slaw.
$24.75
-

Wraps

Buffalo Shrimp Wrap
Zesty fried shrimp tossed with our signature Buffalo sauce, plus lettuce and bleu cheese.
$14.75
-
Chicken Caeser Wrap
Crisp greens, tomato, chunks of grilled chicken with our Caesar dressing.
$12.25
-
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Breaded chicken, Buffalo sauce, bleu cheese and lettuce.
$12.25
-

From the Sea

Alaskan Snow Crab Legs
Steamed and delicious - served with butter, fries, chef's vegetable and homemade coleslaw.
$22.15
-
Disclaimer: Menu-Prices gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.

Search

Close