Navigation
  1. Home »
  2. Restaurants »
  3. Long Island Brothers New York Pizzeria Menu Prices

Long Island Brothers New York Pizzeria Menu Prices

Verified Prices
Menu-Prices is not associated with Long Island Brothers New York Pizzeria
Jump to Section Show
You are viewing Long Island Brothers New York Pizzeria prices confirmed by Menu-Prices at the following location:
14919 Tamiami Trail, North Port, FL 34287 US 1(941) 423-4999
Prices shown in: USD

Popular Items

Large 16"
Eight slices.
$18.50
-
Garlic Knots
Served with fresh made marinara.
$5.25
-
Medium 14"
Six slices.
$15.50
-
Small 10"
Four slices.
$10.50
-
“Bada Bing” Wings
Traditional crispy fried bone-in wings.
$8.99
-
Cannoli
$3.95
-
Create Your Own Calzone (Small)
Two free toppings.
$12.95
-
Create Your Own Stromboli (Small)
Two free toppings.
$12.95
-
Create Your Own Calzone (Large)
Two free toppings.
$18.95
-
Spaghetti
Served with meatballs or sausage.
$15.50
-

Create Your Own Pizza

Small 10" (Create Your Own Pizza)
Four slices.
$10.50
-
Medium 14" (Create Your Own Pizza)
Six slices.
$15.50
-
Large 16" (Create Your Own Pizza)
Eight slices.
$18.50
-
Gluten Free 14"
Six slices.
$15.50
-

Times Square Pizzas

Cut into 12 square slices.
Suffolk County Sicilian
Traditional thick square pizza.
$19.50
-
Grandma Sadie
Thin crust square style pizza with rows of fresh made marinara and Mozzarella. Finished with oregano and fresh basil.
$21.95
-
Grandma Sadie (Times Square Pizzas)
Thin crust square style pizza with rows of fresh made marinara and Mozzarella. Finished with oregano and fresh basil.
$21.95
-
Brooklyn
First comes the Mozzarella, then the sauce on top of a thick square pizza. Finished with EVOO and Parmesan.
$21.95
-

Specialty Pizza

Red: fresh pizza sauce and Mozzarella.
Margherita (Small)
Roma tomatoes, fresh Mozzarella, chopped garlic and fresh made marinara. Finished with fresh basil, Parmesan & EVOO drizzle.
$15.50
-
Margherita (Medium)
Roma tomatoes, fresh Mozzarella, chopped garlic and fresh made marinara. Finished with fresh basil, Parmesan & EVOO drizzle.
$21.00
-
Margherita (Large)
Roma tomatoes, fresh Mozzarella, chopped garlic and fresh made marinara. Finished with fresh basil, Parmesan & EVOO drizzle.
$25.00
-
5 Boroughs (Small)
A blend of five delicious cheeses! Mozzarella, Parmesan, Asiago, Feta and Provolone.
$15.50
-
5 Boroughs (Medium)
A blend of five delicious cheeses! Mozzarella, Parmesan, Asiago, Feta and Provolone.
$21.00
-
5 Boroughs (Large)
A blend of five delicious cheeses! Mozzarella, Parmesan, Asiago, Feta and Provolone.
$25.00
-
Garlic Knot Pie (Small)
Our pizza with fresh made garlic knots baked on to the crust and seasoned to perfection! Served with sides our fresh made marinara.
$15.50
-
Garlic Knot Pie (Medium)
Our pizza with fresh made garlic knots baked on to the crust and seasoned to perfection! Served with sides our fresh made marinara.
$21.00
-
Garlic Knot Pie (Large)
Our pizza with fresh made garlic knots baked on to the crust and seasoned to perfection! Served with sides our fresh made marinara.
$25.00
-
North Morris Ave (Small)
Crispy eggplant, Ricotta cheese, capers, sundried tomatoes, and chopped garlic. Finished with fresh basil, Parmesan and EVOO drizzle.
$16.50
-
North Morris Ave (Medium)
Crispy eggplant, Ricotta cheese, capers, sundried tomatoes, and chopped garlic. Finished with fresh basil, Parmesan and EVOO drizzle.
$22.00
-
North Morris Ave (Large)
Crispy eggplant, Ricotta cheese, capers, sundried tomatoes, and chopped garlic. Finished with fresh basil, Parmesan and EVOO drizzle.
$26.00
-
Strong Island (Small)
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham and bacon.
$16.50
-
Strong Island (Medium)
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham and bacon.
$22.00
-
Strong Island (Large)
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham and bacon.
$26.00
-
Godfather (Small)
Pepperoni, crispy chicken, chopped garlic, Ricotta cheese and jalapeños. Finished with red chili flakes.
$16.50
-
Godfather (Medium)
Pepperoni, crispy chicken, chopped garlic, Ricotta cheese and jalapeños. Finished with red chili flakes.
$22.00
-
Godfather (Large)
Pepperoni, crispy chicken, chopped garlic, Ricotta cheese and jalapeños. Finished with red chili flakes.
$26.00
-
Fuggedaboutit (Small)
Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives and sautéed onion.
$17.50
-
Fuggedaboutit (Medium)
Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives and sautéed onion.
$23.00
-
Fuggedaboutit (Large)
Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives and sautéed onion.
$27.00
-
Brothers Baked Ziti Pizza (Small)
Our fresh made baked ziti topped on a crisp garlic crust with fresh Mozzarella rows of marinara. Finished with Parmesan and basil.
$17.50
-
Brothers Baked Ziti Pizza (Medium)
Our fresh made baked ziti topped on a crisp garlic crust with fresh Mozzarella rows of marinara. Finished with Parmesan and basil.
$23.00
-
Brothers Baked Ziti Pizza (Large)
Our fresh made baked ziti topped on a crisp garlic crust with fresh Mozzarella rows of marinara. Finished with Parmesan and basil.
$27.00
-
Pesto Perfecto! (Small)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Crispy chicken, mushrooms, sautéed onions and Ricotta cheese. Finished with fresh basil pesto and red chili flakes.
$15.50
-
Pesto Perfecto! (Small) (Specialty Pizza)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Crispy chicken, mushrooms, sautéed onions and Ricotta cheese. Finished with fresh basil pesto and red chili flakes.
$15.50
-
Pesto Perfecto! (Medium)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Crispy chicken, mushrooms, sautéed onions and Ricotta cheese. Finished with fresh basil pesto and red chili flakes.
$21.00
-
Pesto Perfecto! (Large)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Crispy chicken, mushrooms, sautéed onions and Ricotta cheese. Finished with fresh basil pesto and red chili flakes.
$25.00
-
Whitestone Bridge (Small)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Ricotta cheese and Mozzarella Finished with Parmesan and EVOO drizzle.
$15.50
-
Whitestone Bridge (Medium)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Ricotta cheese and Mozzarella Finished with Parmesan and EVOO drizzle.
$21.00
-
Whitestone Bridge (Large)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Ricotta cheese and Mozzarella Finished with Parmesan and EVOO drizzle.
$25.00
-
Pizza Caprese (Small)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Fresh Mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil drizzled with EVOO and balsamic glaze.
$15.50
-
Pizza Caprese (Medium)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Fresh Mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil drizzled with EVOO and balsamic glaze.
$21.00
-
Pizza Caprese (Large)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Fresh Mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil drizzled with EVOO and balsamic glaze.
$25.00
-
Boogey Down Buffalo Chicken (Small)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Baked chicken, Blue cheese and chopped parsley topped with Mozzarella.
$17.50
-
Boogey Down Buffalo Chicken (Medium)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Baked chicken, Blue cheese and chopped parsley topped with Mozzarella.
$23.00
-
Boogey Down Buffalo Chicken (Large)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Baked chicken, Blue cheese and chopped parsley topped with Mozzarella.
$27.00
-
Blazin BBQ Chicken (Small)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Baked chicken, sautéed onion, jalapeños and bacon tossed in sweet bbq sauce topped with Mozzarella and Provolone.
$17.50
-
Blazin BBQ Chicken (Medium)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Baked chicken, sautéed onion, jalapeños and bacon tossed in sweet bbq sauce topped with Mozzarella and Provolone.
$23.00
-
Blazin BBQ Chicken (Large)
White: garlic oil crust and Mozzarella (no red sauce). Baked chicken, sautéed onion, jalapeños and bacon tossed in sweet bbq sauce topped with Mozzarella and Provolone.
$27.00
-

Starters

Fried “Mooozadel”
Four pieces. Sliced fresh off the block, breaded and fried golden. Served with fresh made marinara.
$8.99
-
Long Island Lasagna Bombs
Five pieces. Fresh lasagna slices breaded and fried golden. Served with fresh made marinara.
$9.99
-
Garlic Knots (Starters)
Served with fresh made marinara.
$5.25
-
Mama’s Baked Meatballs
Three pieces. Fresh made meatballs Mama’s way, covered in fresh made marinara and Mozzarella.
$8.99
-
Italian Garlic Cheese Bread
Sliced Italian bread with garlic oil spread and oregano topped with Mozzarella.
$7.95
-
“Bada Bing” Wings (Starters)
Traditional crispy fried bone-in wings.
$8.99
-

Salads

Long Island House Salad (Half Salad)
Fresh greens, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, black olives and croutons.
$7.95
-
Long Island House Salad (Half Salad) (Salads)
Fresh greens, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, black olives and croutons.
$7.95
-
Long Island House Salad (Full Salad)
Fresh greens, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, black olives and croutons.
$11.50
-
Caesar Salad (Half Salad)
Fresh romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan and croutons.
$7.95
-
Caprese (Half Salad)
Fresh Mozzarella, tomatoes and basil drizzled with EVOO and balsamic glaze.
$7.95
-
Caesar Salad (Full Salad)
Fresh romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan and croutons.
$11.50
-
Caprese (Full Salad)
Fresh Mozzarella, tomatoes and basil drizzled with EVOO and balsamic glaze.
$11.50
-
Greek Salad (Half Salad)
Fresh greens, tomatoes, onion, Kalamata olives, banana peppers and Feta cheese.
$7.95
-
Greek Salad (Full Salad)
Fresh greens, tomatoes, onion, Kalamata olives, banana peppers and Feta cheese.
$11.50
-
Papa Joe’s Antipasto (Half Salad)
Fresh bed of greens topped with pepperoni, ham, salami, Provolone, roasted rep peppers, artichoke hearts, black and green olives.
$7.95
-
Papa Joe’s Antipasto (Full Salad)
Fresh bed of greens topped with pepperoni, ham, salami, Provolone, roasted rep peppers, artichoke hearts, black and green olives.
$11.50
-

Calzone

Stuffed with Ricotta, Parmesan and Mozzarella and finished with garlic oil. Served with fresh made marinara.
Create Your Own Calzone (Small) (Calzone)
Two free toppings.
$12.95
-
Create Your Own Calzone (Large) (Calzone)
Two free toppings.
$18.95
-
Specialty Calzone (Small)
Buffalo chicken, Italian job, stuffed lasagna, chicken Parmesan.
$15.95
-
Specialty Calzone (Large)
Buffalo chicken, Italian job, stuffed lasagna, chicken Parmesan.
$21.95
-

Stromboli

Stuffed with Mozzarella and finished with garlic oil. Served with fresh made marinara.
Create Your Own Stromboli (Small) (Stromboli)
Two free toppings.
$12.95
-
Create Your Own Stromboli (Large) (Stromboli)
Two free toppings.
$18.95
-
Create Your Own Stromboli (Large)
Two free toppings.
$18.95
-
Specialty Stromboli (Small)
Buffalo chicken, Italian job, stuffed lasagna, chicken Parmesan.
$15.95
-
Specialty Stromboli (Large)
Buffalo chicken, Italian job, stuffed lasagna, chicken Parmesan.
$21.95
-

Heroes

Prepared in freshly made 12 inches Italian bread.
Chicken Parmesan
$12.95
-
Eggplant Parmesan
$12.95
-
Meatball Parmesan
$12.95
-
Meatball Parmesan (Heroes)
$12.95
-
Sausage Parmesan
$12.95
-
Long Island Expressway
Sausage, peppers and sautéed onions tossed in fresh made marinara topped with Provolone cheese.
$13.95
-
Jones Beach
Fresh Mozzarella, artichoke hearts, tomatoes, roasted red peppers on garlic toasted Italian bread topped with basil pesto and fresh greens.
$13.95
-
Belt Parkway
Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, melted fresh Mozzarella, topped with fresh greens served with honey balsamic.
$13.95
-
Great Bambino
Sliced Genoa salami, pepperoni, capicola and Provolone, topped with shredded lettuce, onion and tomatoes. Served with Italian dressing. Your preference hot or cold.
$13.95
-
Philly Cheese Steak
We may be from New York, but we sure know how to make a mean Philly! Our Philly comes with mushroom, peppers & onions.
$14.95
-

Pasta Dinners

Served with bread.
Spaghetti (Pasta Dinners)
Served with meatballs or sausage.
$15.50
-
Baked Ziti
Ziti pasta mixed with Ricotta, fresh made Marinara and Mozzarella then baked.
$15.50
-
Baked Ravioli
Cheese filled pasta baked with fresh made marinara and Mozzarella.
$15.50
-
Lasagna
Stuffed with meat sauce and Ricotta cheese.
$16.50
-
Chicken Parmesan (Pasta Dinners)
Tender hand breaded chicken breast baked with fresh made marinara and Mozzarella served over spaghetti or ziti.
$17.50
-
Eggplant Parmesan (Pasta Dinners)
Tender hand breaded eggplant baked with fresh made marinara and Mozzarella served over spaghetti or ziti.
$17.50
-

Desserts

Cannoli (Desserts)
$3.95
-
Chocolate Cannoli
$4.50
-
NY High-Rise Cheesecake
$7.50
-
Tirimisu
$7.50
-
Limoncello Mascarpone Cake
$7.50
-

Beverages

2 Liter Coke
$5.88
-
Manhattan Special Espresso Coffee Soda
12oz glass bottle
$5.00
-
Olde Brooklyn Ginger Ale
12oz glass bottle
$4.50
-
2 Liter Diet Coke
$5.88
-
Olde Brooklyn Black Cherry
12oz glass bottle
$4.50
-
Olde Brooklyn Cream Soda
12oz glass bottle
$4.50
-
Olde Brooklyn Root Beer
12oz glass bottle
$4.50
-
2 Liter Sprite
$5.88
-
2 Liter Mountain Dew
$5.88
-

Extra Sides/Dressings

Add extra sides of your favorite sauces & dressings!
Ranch Dressing
$1.00
-
Caesar Dressing
$1.00
-
Greek Dressing
$1.00
-
Honey Balsamic Dressing
$1.00
-
Blue Cheese Dressing
$1.00
-
Italian Dressing
$1.00
-
Marinara Sauce
$1.00
-
Pizza Sauce
$1.00
-
Hot Sauce
$1.00
-
Sweet BBQ Sauce
$1.00
-
Chipolte BBQ Sauce
$1.00
-
Buffalo Ranch Sauce
$1.00
-
Mild Sauce
$1.00
-
Parmesan Garlic Sauce
$1.00
-

By the Slice

Cheese
$2.95
-
Sicilian
$3.25
-

Catering Menu

Sautéed Broccoli (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$30.00
-
Sautéed Broccoli (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$45.00
-
Meatballs (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$30.00
-
Meatballs (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$45.00
-
Ziti & Broccoli (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$35.00
-
Ziti & Broccoli (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$60.00
-
Spaghetti & Meatballs (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$35.00
-
Spaghetti & Meatballs (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$60.00
-
Baked Ziti (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$40.00
-
Baked Ziti (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$65.00
-
Baked Ravioli (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$40.00
-
Baked Ravioli (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$60.00
-
Sausage & Peppers (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$45.00
-
Sausage & Peppers (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$70.00
-
Eggplant Parmesan (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$50.00
-
Eggplant Parmesan (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$75.00
-
Chicken Parmesan (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$50.00
-
Chicken Parmesan (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$75.00
-
Eggplant Rollatini (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$50.00
-
Eggplant Rollatini (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$75.00
-
Lasagna (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$55.00
-
Lasagna (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$80.00
-
House Salad (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$20.00
-
House Salad (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$35.00
-
Caesar Salad (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$25.00
-
Caesar Salad (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$40.00
-
Antipasto Salad (Half)
Half tray serves five to eight persons.
$35.00
-
Antipasto Salad (Full)
Half tray serves 10 to 14 persons.
$50.00
-
Disclaimer: Menu-Prices gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.

Search

Close