Navigation
  1. Home »
  2. Restaurants »
  3. Coney Island Cafe Menu Prices

Coney Island Cafe Menu Prices

Verified Prices
Menu-Prices is not associated with Coney Island Cafe
Jump to Section Show
You are viewing Coney Island Cafe prices confirmed by Menu-Prices at the following location:
10 Railroad Avenue, Middletown, NY 10940 US 1(845) 343-3714
Prices shown in: USD

Popular Items

Spicy Chicken BLT Wrap
Grilled chicken breast, topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato, melted cheddar, finished with chipotle sauce in a whole wheat tortilla.
$8.69
-
Spicy Chicken BLT Wrap ?️
Grilled chicken breast, topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato, melted cheddar, finished with chipotle sauce in a whole wheat tortilla.
$8.98
-
Chicken Avocado Sandwich
Grilled chicken, topped with swiss cheese and avocado, served with lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a bun.
$8.96
+3.94%
Fajita Chicken Salad ?️
Cajun chicken, roamine, corn, black beans, tomato, tortilla chips, chipotle ranch dressing.
$9.96
-
Fajita Chicken Salad
Cajun chicken, roamine, corn, black beans, tomato, tortilla chips, chipotle ranch dressing.
$9.67
-

Breakfast Specials

Served from 6:30 AM to 11:00 AM. Served with choice of coffee, tea or hot chocolate.
English Breakfast
Scrambled egg whites, ham and American cheese on a toasted English muffin.
$5.12
+6.00%
French Toast Special
$7.12
-
Two Eggs with Home Fries & Toast
$5.12
-2.66%
Ham & Cheese Omelette
$8.76
-
Huevos Rancheros
Two 6" tortillas grilled with refried beans, cheddar cheese and over easy eggs. Topped with salsa and guacamole.
$9.12
+4.11%
Pancakes Special
$6.98
-
Oatmeal Special
$3.63
-
Oatmeal
$3.46
-
Two Eggs with Toast, No Potatoes
$3.94
-
Two Eggs with Toast No Potatoes
$3.76
-
Western Omelette
Made with ham, peppers and onions.
$9.24
+5.96%
Western Omelette (Breakfast Specials)
Made with ham, peppers and onions.
$9.24
-
Egg Quesadillas
Wheat tortilla stuffed with eggs scrambled with tomatoes, peppers onions, choice of bacon or sausage with melted jack cheese served with salsa and guacamole.
$9.86
-
Eggs Quesadillas
Wheat tortilla stuffed with eggs scrambled with tomatoes, peppers onions, choice of bacon or sausage with melted jack cheese served with salsa and guacamole.
$9.52
-

Breakfast Breads & Pasteries

Buttered Toast
$1.20
+4.35%
Croissant
$2.18
+4.81%
Croissant with Cream Cheese
$2.98
+3.83%
Buttered Roll
$1.59
+4.61%
Assorted Muffins
$2.32
+4.98%
Toasted Bagel
$2.08
+5.58%
Toasted Bagel with Cream Cheese
$2.92
+5.04%
English Muffin
$2.06
+4.57%

Say Hello to the Benedicts!

All benedicts include a side of homefries.
Mexi Benedict ?️
2 poached eggs served with refried beans on a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce then drizzled with chipotle sauce.
$8.92
-
Chipotle Bacon Benedict ?️
2 poached eggs served with crisp bacon and guacamole on a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce, drizzled with chipotle sauce.
$9.26
-
California Benedict
2 poached eggs over grilled tomato, fresh avocado on a toasted English muffin and finished with hollandaise.
$8.92
-
Irish Benedict
2 poached eggs, served over housemade corned beef has and a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise sauce.
$8.92
-
Classic Benedict
2 poached eggs on a grilled Canadian bacon on a toasted English muffin topped with hollandaise.
$8.92
-

Breakfast Sandwiches

Bacon, Tomato, & Avocado Croissant
Scrambled eggs, bacon, tomato and avocado on a croissant.
$7.50
-
Fried Egg & Cheese
Fried Egg & Cheese on a Roll
$3.08
+5.48%
Western Egg & Cheese
$5.22
+4.82%
Croissant Sausage, Egg & Cheese
$5.39
-
Sausage, Egg & Cheese Croissant
$5.57
-
Ultimate Egg Sandwich
Fried egg, bacon, American cheese, home fries & jalapeños on a Brioche roll.
$6.18
+7.29%

Breakfast Wraps & Sandwiches

Ultimate Wrap ?️
Two scrambled eggs, home fries, sausage, jalapeños, pepper jack cheese in a wheat wrap.
$6.36
-
Ultimate Wrap
Two scrambled eggs, home fries, sausage, jalapeños, pepper jack cheese in a wheat wrap.
$6.36
-
Meat Lovers
Wrap with sausage, bacon, onions, peppers, two scrambled eggs and swiss cheese in a wheat wrap.
$6.36
-
Mediterranean Wrap
Three egg whites, fresh mozzarella, tomato in a wheat wrap.
$5.94
-
Bacon, Tomato, Avocado
Scrambled eggs, bacon, tomato and avocado on a croissant.
$6.36
-

He-Man Breakfast

Steak & Eggs
Five ounce sirloin steak served with two eggs, home fries and toast.
$10.27
-
Mediterranean Skillet
Three scrambled eggs, over home fries, roasted red peppers, diced tomatoes and spinach, topped with feta cheese, served with choice of toast.
$9.12
-
Three Meat Spicy Skillet
Ham, bacon and sausage topped with two eggs scrambled, green peppers, pepper jack cheese, over home fries, served with choice of toast.
$9.58
-
French Delight
Two slices French toast, two eggs served with bacon.
$9.64
-
Grand Slam
Two eggs with ham, bacon and sausage served with home fries and choice of pancakes or French toast.
$9.83
-

Signature Omelets

Spicy Avocado Omelette ?️
Grilled onions, peppers, avocado, and pepper jack cheese, drizzled with chipotle sauce
$9.54
-
Coney Island Omelette
Two franks, cheese, onions and chili sauce.
$9.54
+2.91%
Caprese Omelette
Tomato, melted mozzarella cheese, chopped basil and toast.
$9.06
-
Western Omelette (Signature Omelets)
Made with ham, peppers and onions.
$9.06
-
Farmers Omelette
Ham, onions, peppers, bacon, sausage and cheese.
$9.54
-
Grecian Omelette
Spinach, feta cheese and tomatoes.
$8.49
+3.92%
Chicken Fajita Omelette
Chicken, pepper jack cheese, onions and peppers served with salsa and sour cream.
$9.86
+2.92%
Tex Mex Omelette
Red and green peppers, sautéed onions and peppers jack cheese.
$9.54
+2.91%

Eggs and Omelettes

Breakfast served all day
One Egg with No Potatoes
$2.58
+4.03%
Two Eggs
$3.08
-31.25%
Broccoli Omelette
$7.26
-
Two Eggs with No Potatoes
$2.98
-
Ham Omelette
$7.62
-
Bacon Omelette
$7.62
-
Sausage Omelette
$7.62
-
Cheese Omelette
$6.83
-
Mushroom Omelette
$7.26
-

Bread and Bagels

Pancakes & French Toast

Pancakes
$6.27
-6.97%
Pancakes (Pancakes & French Toast)
$5.96
-
Blueberry Cakes
$7.37
-
Short Stack French Toast
$4.42
+8.60%
Cinnastack Pancakes
Pancakes layered with cinnamon spread topped with cream cheese icing.
$8.29
+3.88%
French Toast
$6.42
-6.96%
French Toast (Pancakes & French Toast)
$6.42
-
Short Stack Pancakes
$4.27
+4.91%
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
$6.42
+3.88%
Strawberry Fields
Three thick slices french toast topped with strawberry compote and whipped cream.
$7.38
+4.09%
Banana Bread French Toast
Our delicious homemade banana bread topped with bananas, cinnamon and powdered sugar.
$7.48
+4.18%

Starters

Choose from a delicious array of starters to get your lunch or dinner started
Fresh Potato Chips
Sliced fresh and fried to perfection.
$3.25
-

Salads

Fajita Chicken Salad (Salads)
Cajun chicken, roamine, corn, black beans, tomato, tortilla chips, chipotle ranch dressing.
$9.67
-

Appetizers & Soups

Choose from a delicious array of starters to get your lunch or dinner started
Chili Con Carne
$4.57
-
Homemade Fried Green Beans
Fresh green beans lightly battered & fried to perfection, served with ranch
$6.98
-
Over Loaded Potato Skins
Topped with cheddar jack cheese, bacon, diced onions, tomato, jalapeños, and black olives, served with sour cream on the side.
$6.98
+3.87%
French Fries
Fried to perfection.
$4.37
+4.55%
Chili Cheese Fries
French fries topped with our signature chili sauce and shredded cheese.
$6.42
+3.88%
Sweet Potato French Fries
Sweet potato sliced and fried to perfection.
$4.92
+5.35%
Bacon Cheese Fries
French fries, with melted cheese, and crisp bacon pieces, served with a side of ranch.
$6.57
+4.62%

Triple Deckers

Served with potato chips, pickle and slaw
Sliced Turkey
Lettuce, tomato and bacon.
$8.96
-
Sliced Roast Beef
Lettuce, tomato, bacon, American cheese.
$8.96
-
Sliced Ham
Lettuce, tomato, swiss cheese.
$8.96
-

Glorius Salads

Grecian Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken, shredded romaine lettuce, peppers, onions, and diced tomatoes served with tzatziki sauce.
$9.98
-
Chef Salad
Fresh lettuce, turkey, roast beef, ham, swiss cheese, tomato and cucumbers, garnished with a hard boiled egg.
$10.27
+2.91%
Fajita Chicken Salad ?️ (Glorius Salads)
Cajun chicken, roamine, corn, black beans, tomato, tortilla chips, chipotle ranch dressing.
$9.96
-
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Grilled and sliced breast of chicken over romaine, shredded cheddar jack cheese, diced tomatoes, chopped bacon and ranch.
$10.27
+3.53%
Caesar Salad
Romaine, tossed, with Caesar dressing, freshly grated parmesan cheese and fresh made croutons.
$7.93
+3.93%
California Supreme Salad
Breast of chicken, grilled and sliced over salad with tomato, cucumbers, onions, shredded cheese, choice of dressing.
$9.97
+3.00%
Pepper Jack Chicken Romaine
Crispy romaine lettuce, topped with grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, pepper jack cheese and chipotle ranch dressing.
$9.62
-

Coney Island Combo Meals

Choose your meal, choose your side and choose your drink
Coney Dog Combo
$7.12
+4.40%
Cheeseburger Combo
$8.96
+8.87%
Coney Cheesesteak Combo
$11.87
+6.17%
Greek Gyro
$11.87
+6.17%
Double Cheeseburger
$9.27
-
Chicken Wings
$5.49
+4.97%
Chicken Tender Combo
$10.76
+5.28%

Hand Pressed Burgers

Served with french fries, cole slaw, and pickle. Substitute sweet potatoes or onion rings $.98 extra
Chipotle Bacon Burger
Pepper jack cheese, bacon, red onions, chipotle sauce in a whole wheat tortilla.
$7.18
-
Spicy Philly Burger ?️
Our hand-pressed burger topped with melted cheddar cheese, sautéed onions, jalapeños, and chipotle sauce on a hamburger bun.
$7.46
-
Chipotle Bacon Burger ?️
Pepper jack cheese, bacon, red onions, chipotle sauce in a whole wheat tortilla.
$7.46
-
Cajun Bacon Pepper Jack Burger
Our hand pressed burger Cajun-seasoned, topped with melted pepper jack cheese and bacon on a hamburger bun.
$7.46
+3.90%
Swiss Melt Burger
With fried onions, mushrooms, melted swiss cheese on rye.
$7.46
+3.90%

Paninis, Wraps, Melts

Served with potato chips, pickle and cole slaw
Pepper Jack Pastrami Wrap
Thin sliced and grilled pastrami, with pepper jack cheese, roasted red peppers and mayo in a wheat tortilla.
$8.69
-
Spicy Chicken BLT Wrap (Paninis, Wraps, Melts)
Grilled chicken breast, topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato, melted cheddar, finished with chipotle sauce in a whole wheat tortilla.
$8.69
-
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Buffalo crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing in a wheat tortilla.
$8.17
-

Delicious Paninis, Wraps, Melts

Served with potato chips, pickle, and cole slaw. Substitute fries $.98 extra, sub sweet potato fries or onion rings $1.85 extra
Chipotle Chicken Wrap ?️
Grilled chicken topped with crispy bacon, shredded cheddar jack cheese, tomato, and chipotle sauce in a wheat tortilla.
$8.98
-
Hickory Chicken Melt
Grilled chicken breast topped with melted Swiss cheese, crispy bacon, and BBQ sauce on grilled rye bread.
$7.98
-
Turkey Melt
Grilled American cheese with turkey, tomato and russian dressing on rye bread.
$7.93
+3.93%
Tuscan Roast Beef Panini
Roast beef, thin sliced and grilled, topped with melted mozzarella cheese, sauteed spinach and tomatoes on grilled rye.
$8.98
+3.34%
Pepperjack Pastrami Wrap
Thin sliced and grilled pastrami, with pepper jack cheese, roasted red peppers and mayo in a wheat tortilla.
$8.98
-
Philly Roast Beef Melt
Roast beef, sliced thin and grilled, topped with melted cheddar cheese and sautéed onions on grilled rye.
$8.98
+3.34%
Spicy Chicken BLT Wrap ?️ (Delicious Paninis, Wraps, Melts)
Grilled chicken breast, topped with bacon, lettuce, tomato, melted cheddar, finished with chipotle sauce in a whole wheat tortilla.
$8.98
-
Buffalo Chicken Wrap ?️
Buffalo crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing in a wheat tortilla.
$8.49
-
Crispy Chicken Wrap
Crisp fried chicken, lettuce, tomato, avocado, shredded cheese, bacon, cucumber and honey mustard in a wheat tortilla.
$9.33
+3.90%

Signature Sandwiches

All served with chips, cole slaw, and pickle. Substitute sweet potato fries or onions rings $.98 extra.
French Dip
Thinly sliced roast beef and melted Swiss cheese on a baguette brushed with garlic butter with au jus on the side. Add onions and mushrooms for an additional charge.
$10.16
+5.07%
Grilled Reuben
Lean corned beef and sauerkraut topped with melted Swiss cheese on rye bread, with Russian dressing on the side.
$9.96
+3.00%
Chicken Avocado Sandwich (Signature Sandwiches)
Grilled chicken, topped with swiss cheese and avocado, served with lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a bun.
$8.96
+3.94%
Corned Beef & Pastrami Combo
Corned beef and pastrami on rye.
$8.96
-
Corned Beef Pastrami Combo
Corned beef, pastrami, on rye.
$8.62
-

Tasty Sandwiches

Served with potato chips, pickle, and cole slaw.
Roast Beef with Lettuce
$7.36
+3.95%
Sliced Ham Triple Decker
Ham, lettuce, tomato, and Swiss cheese.
$9.32
-
Sliced Roast Beef Triple Decker
Roast beef, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and American cheese.
$9.32
-
Sliced Turkey Triple Decker
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
$9.32
-
Virginia Ham with Lettuce
$7.36
+3.95%
Chicken Salad with Lettuce
$6.98
+3.87%
Roast Turkey with Lettuce
$7.36
+3.95%
BLT
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise
$5.42
+5.04%
Egg Salad with Lettuce
$5.87
-
Grilled Cheese
$4.27
-

Cincinnati Style Chili

Taste spaghetti like you've never tried it before! Topped with our authentic chili sauce recipe
Three Way
Spaghetti with chili sauce and shredded cheese.
$5.79
+4.89%
Four Way
Spaghetti, chili sauce, shredded cheese and onions.
$6.12
+4.79%
Five Way
Spaghetti, chili sauce, shredded cheese, onions and kidney beans.
$6.73
+3.86%

Hot Entrees

Served with mashed potatoes and vegetables
Hot Open Turkey
Topped with brown gravy.
$9.97
+3.00%
Hot Open Sirloin of Beef
Topped with brown gravy.
$9.97
+3.00%
Hot Open Virginia Ham
Served with mashed potatoes.
$9.97
+3.00%

Mexican Fiesta

Chicken & Black Bean Quesadilla
Wheat tortilla stuffed with grilled chicken, shredded cheese, corn salsa and black beans, served with salsa, sour cream and guacamole.
$9.34
+4.01%
Burrito
Wheat tortilla filled with seasoned beef, refried beans and shredded cheese, topped with lettuce, tomato, salsa and sour cream.
$8.47
+3.55%
Fajita Quesadillas
Wheat tortilla filled with grilled chicken and shredded cheese, topped with lettuce, tomato, served with salsa, sour cream and guacamole.
$8.49
+3.92%

Side Orders

Bacon
$2.64
+4.76%
Sausage
$2.64
+4.76%
Ham
$2.64
+4.76%
Turkey Sausage
$3.12
+4.70%
French Fries (Side Orders)
$4.37
+4.80%
Sweet Potato Fries
$5.12
+5.35%
Cole Slaw
$2.82
+4.83%
Fries
$4.37
-
Corned Beef Hash
House made corned beef.
$4.79
+4.81%
Home Fries
$3.59
+4.97%
Onion Rings
$5.12
+5.35%
Fries with Mozzarella Gravy
$5.49
-
Fries with Mozzarella Cheese
$5.49
-
Mac & Cheese
$3.72
+7.51%
Sirloin Steak
$5.22
-
Disclaimer: Menu-Prices gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.

Search

Close