Navigation
  1. Home »
  2. Restaurants »
  3. Cape May Peanut Butter Co Menu Prices

Cape May Peanut Butter Co Menu Prices

Verified Prices
Menu-Prices is not associated with Cape May Peanut Butter Co
Jump to Section Show
You are viewing Cape May Peanut Butter Co prices confirmed by Menu-Prices at the following location:
516 Carpenter Lane, Cape May, NJ 08204 US 1(609) 898-4444
Prices shown in: USD

Nut Butters

Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butters. Honey roast, natural, organic, butter scotch, chocolate, capu cino, almond, cashew, sunflower.
Maple Vanilla Small Batch Peanut Butter (8 ounces - 0.65 lbs.)
You'll love this deliciously creamy maple vanilla peanut butter these limited edition small batch butters are only around for a limited time so do not delay and order yours today.
$6.95
-
Butter Scotch
Our butterscotch peanut butter is made with roasted peanuts and butterscotch pieces. Try spreading this on top of a piece of pound cake for a tasty snack! Ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, butterscotch drops, brown sugar, natural flavor, soybean oil. Serving size - two tablespoons. 8 ounces - 0.80 lbs., 16 ounces - 1.25 lbs., 32 ounces - 2.45 lbs.
$4.99
-
Honey Roast
This is our #1 selling nut butter! Eat it by the spoonful or put with anything you can imagine using peanut butter on! This is a great nut butter for anything! Ingredients: peanuts, sugar, honey, potato starch, maltodextrin, peanut oil, salt, and xanthan gum. Serving size - two tablespoons. 8 ounces - 0.80 lbs., 16 ounces - 1.25 lbs., 32 ounces - 2.45 lbs.
$4.99
-
Capu Cino
Ingredients: roasted peanuts, butterscotch drops, cinnamon drops, Non-GMO canola oil, dextrose, coffee, dutch cocoa powder, natural flavorings. Serving size - two tablespoons. 8 ounces - 0.80 lbs., 16 ounces - 1.25 lbs., 32 ounces - 2.45 lbs.
$4.99
-
Choc Choc
Our chocolate peanut butter is made with roasted peanuts and chocolate chips. Spread this on pancakes for a special meal! Ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, semi-sweet pure chocolate drops (contains: milk and soy). Serving size - two tablespoons. 8 ounces - 0.80 lbs., 16 ounces - 1.25 lbs., 32 ounces - 2.45 lbs.
$4.99
-
Large PB&J Gift Pack with Spreader
PB&J gift pack with spreader! Plus, you get to choose your butters and a jelly from our selection.
$29.99
-
Mini PB&J Pack
This mini PB&J pack makes a great sandwich and a great gift! Choose between four great nut butters and three jams!
$6.99
-
Natural Almond
Our almond butter is made with nothing other than roasted almonds! Ingredients: dry roasted almonds. Serving size - two tablespoons. 8 ounces - 0.80 lbs., 16 ounces - 1.25 lbs., 32 ounces - 2.45 lbs.
$7.99
-
Natural Cashew (8 Ounces - 0.80 lbs.)
Natural cashew. Ingredients: roasted cashews, salt. Serving size - two tablespoons.
$9.99
-
Natural Peanut
Our natural peanut butter is made with dry roasted peanuts and salt. Great for baking, smoothies and much more! Ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, salt. Serving size - two tablespoons. 8 ounces - 0.80 lbs., 16 ounces - 1.25 lbs., 32 ounces - 2.45 lbs.
$4.49
-
Natural Sunflower (8 Ounces - 0.80 lbs.)
Natural sunflower. Ingredients: roasted sunflower kernels, sunflower oil (sunflower oil, citric acid), salt.
$4.99
-
Organic Peanut
Ingredients: dry roasted organic peanuts. Serving size - two tablespoons. 8 ounces - 0.75 lbs., 16 ounces - 1.25 lbs., 32 ounces - 2.35 lbs.
$5.99
-
Peanut Butter Party Box
It's party time at cape may peanut butter company! You'll love our new party box filled with 5 great nut butters. Honey roast, butter scotch, capu cino, choc choc and natural peanut! Plus, it comes with a handy PB spreader. This party box also makes a great gift for the PB lover in your life! Five 3 oz. jars. 2.0 lbs.
$29.95
-

Powdered Peanut Butter

Butter Scotch Powdered Peanut Butter (0.8 Ounces - 0.10 lbs.)
Butter scotch powdered peanut butter is the perfect on the go snack.
$1.50
-
Choc Choc Powdered Peanut Butter (0.8 Ounces - 0.10 lbs.)
Choc choc powdered peanut butter is the perfect on the go snack.
$1.50
-
Natural Peanut Powdered Peanut Butter (0.8 Ounces - 0.10 lbs.)
Natural peanut powdered peanut butter is the perfect on the go snack.
$1.50
-

Jellies & Jams

Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies and preserves! Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeño, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeño, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeño, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeño, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeño, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Apricot Pecan Preserves (1.00 lbs.)
$9.95
-
Cranberry Chili Pecan Preserves (1.00 lbs.)
$9.95
-
Jalapeño Peach Pecan Preserves (1.00 lbs.)
$9.95
-
Peach Pecan Amaretto Preserves (1.00 lbs.)
$9.95
-
Apricot Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Black Currant Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Blackberry Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Boysenberry Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Lingonberry Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Raspberry Rhubarb Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Strawberry Rhubarb Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Wild Blueberry Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Apple Butter by Brooklyn Whatever (0.90 lbs.)
This is a highly concentrated form of apple sauce. It’s made by long, slow cooking of apples till caramelized. It’s spreadable and so good on crackers, fruit or right out of the jar with a spoon.
$7.99
-
Black Raspberry Jam (Sugarless) by Mrs. Miller's (18 Ounces - 1.25 lbs.)
Ingredients:black raspberry puree, white grape juice concentrate and/or apple juice, pectin, citric acid, vinegar. Naturally sweet, no granulated sugar added. Hand scooped in Ohio's amish country.
$8.95
-
Blackberry Jam (Seedless) by Mrs. Miller's (18 Ounces - 1.25 lbs.)
Made from the plumpest, most delicious blackberries, mrs. Miller's homemade seedless blackberry jam is a delicious combo of sweetness and tartness. One of the most historically familiar flavors of jam, this can be used as a pie filling, a glaze for your meats or as a topping on your toast, muffin or biscuit. Hand scooped in Ohio's amish country.
$8.95
-
Blazing Blueberry Jam by Brooklyn Whatever (0.90 lbs.)
Smooth, spreadable blazing blueberry jam.
$7.99
-
Blueberry Bourbon Jam (1.00 lbs.)
Whole Maine blueberries and brown sugar with a touch of bourbon give this jam a rich flavor. Spoon over ice cream, fill cakes or perk up your morning toast.
$9.95
-
Brooklyn Whatever Jam (0.80 lbs.)
Brooklyn whatever jams! Great flavors that include apple butter, rockin' raspberry, cherry jalapeño, hot pepper, peppery peach, jalapeño and blazin blueberry.
$7.99
-
Bumbleberry Jam by Mrs. Miller's (18 Ounces - 1.25 lbs.)
Made from a combination of three of everyone's favorite fruits: strawberries, blueberries and red raspberries, mrs. Miller's homemade bumbleberry jam is literally bursting with flavor. Try it out on your next muffin or toast or use it to create the best PB&J sandwich you have ever tasted. Hand scooped in Ohio's amish country.
$8.95
-
Carrot Cake Jam (1.00 lbs.)
Potlicker jam - carrot cake.
$9.95
-
Cherry Jalapeño Jam (0.90 lbs.)
Cherries and jalapeños blended into a jam. So unique and delicious. Not too spicy, not too sweet, this one’s just right.
$7.99
-
Cherry Pecan Preserves
Cherries and jalapeños blended into a jam. So unique and delicious. Not too spicy, not too sweet, this one’s just right.
$9.95
-
Dutch Apple Jam by Mrs. Miller's (8 Ounces - 0.75 lbs.)
Cooked with delicious apples and pure cane sugar, mrs. Miller's homemade dutch apple jam reminds everyone of homemade apple pie. Get a real taste of amish country when you scoop this onto your next slice of homemade bread or use it as filling or glaze for your pies. Hand scooped in Ohio's amish country.
$5.95
-
Elderberry Jam by Mrs. Miller's (18 Ounces - 1.25 lbs.)
Ingredients: sugar, elderberries, water, pectin, lemon juice, citric acid. All natural, no corn syrup. Hand scooped in Ohio's amish country.
$8.95
-
F.R.O.G. Jam by Mrs. Miller's (8 ounces -0.75 lbs.)
This flavor may have a unique name, but its combination of familiar flavors yields a delightful taste. Made with delicious figs, raspberries, oranges and ginger, mrs. Miller's homemade frog jam is a local favorite. Spread it on your next slice of toast, muffin or biscuit and enjoy the frog combination of flavors for yourself. Hand scooped in Ohio's amish country.
$5.95
-
Hefeweizen with Orange Beer Jelly (1.00 lbs.)
This light and fruity beer jelly is bursting with citrus undertones. Awesome as a salmon glaze or top your English muffin! Pair with fresh goat cheese.
$9.95
-
Hot Pepper Jam by Brooklyn Whatever (0.90 lbs.)
A mix of hot peppers and sugar to form a spread that will wake up everything you put it on.
$7.99
-
Jalapeño Jam (0.90 lbs.)
Smooth, spreadable jalapeño jam for those who like it hot. Great on sandwiches or as a dip.
$7.99
-
Large PB&J Gift Pack with Spreader (Jellies & Jams)
PB&J gift pack with spreader! Plus, you get to choose your butters and a jelly from our selection.
$29.99
-
Mango Jam by Mrs. Miller's (8 ounces - 0.75 lbs.)
Made with sweet tropical mango fruit, mrs. Miller's homemade mango jam is a tasty tropical jam. The mango fruit is known as the king of fruits and originates in Southeast asia. It is known for its sweet luscious taste and nutritional qualities. Mangoes are rich in vitamins and antioxidants. Most importantly though, they result in a delicious jam that will give you a wonderful spread on your toast without requiring a journey to Southeast asia to harvest them. Hand scooped in Ohio's amish country.
$5.95
-
Mini PB&J Pack (Jellies & Jams)
This Mini PB&J Pack makes a great sandwich and a great gift! choose between four great nut butters and three jams!
$6.99
-
Oatmeal Stout Jelly (1.00 lbs.)
Potlicker beer jelly - oatmeal stout.
$9.95
-
Peach Jam (sugarless) by Mrs. Miller's (18 oz. - 1.25 lbs.)
Ingredients: peaches, white grape juice concentrate and/or apple juice, pectin, citric acid, vinegar. Naturally sweet - no granulated sugar added. Hand scooped in Ohio's amish country.
$8.95
-
Peppery Peach Jam by Brooklyn Whatever (0.90 lbs.)
Smooth, spreadable peppery peach.
$7.99
-
Porter Beer Jelly (1.00 lbs.)
A bold beer flavor, with a chocolatey aroma. Pair this jelly with barbecued meats, buttery cheeses, baked goods, or on a grown-up PB&J.
$9.95
-
Raspberry Smoked Maple Jam (1.00 lbs.)
Raspberry jam sweetened with pure maple syrup, tapped and infused with hardwood smoke in landgrove, VT. A favorite in our kitchen, this jam is equally at home in sweet, and savory applications, from cakes to funky cheese plates.
$9.95
-
Red Raspberry Jam by Mrs. Miller's (18 ounces - 1.25 lbs.)
Made with the sweetest sun ripened red raspberries, mrs. Miller's homemade red raspberry jam has just the right combination of sweetness and tartness. One taste of this flavor will take you right back to picking your own raspberries on the farm. This delicious jam tastes great on toast, muffin or bagel or add it to your oatmeal to sweeten up your breakfast! Hand scooped in Ohio's amish country.
$8.95
-
Rockin' Raspberry Jam by Brooklyn Whatever (0.90 lbs.)
Smooth, spreadable rockin' raspberry jam.
$7.99
-
Strawberry Jam (Sugarless) by Mrs. Miller's (18 ounces - 1.25 lbs.)
Ingredients: red raspberries, white grape juice concentrate and/or apple juice, pectin, citric acid, vinegar. Naturally sweet - no granulated sugar added. Hand scooped in Ohio's amish country.
$8.95
-

Candy

Peanut Butter Malted Milk Balls (0.46 lbs.)
Peanut butter malted milk balls.
$8.50
-
Peanut Butter Non-Pareils (0.55 lbs.)
You'll love these delicious PB non-pareils so much you may not want to share!
$7.95
-
Cocoa Dusted Chocolate Cashews (3 Ounces - 0.30 lbs.)
Seriously, you'll love these delicious cocoa dusted chocolate cashews so much you won't want to share. You may even hide these from loved ones. And that's ok by us, we don't judge!
$5.95
-
Dream Box (7 Ounces - 1.00 lbs.)
The dream box contains three of our most popular candies. PB chocolate clusters, PB nonpareils and candied coconut peanuts.
$9.99
-
Gourmet Candy Covered Pretzels (1.10 lbs.)
$15.95
-
Peanut Butter Cookie Dough (1.10 lbs.)
It's here. Peanut butter cookie dough! Eat it, don't bake it!
$9.99
-
Peanut Butter Cup (1.10 lbs.)
You'll love these colossal peanut butter cups from the cape may peanut butter company!
$6.95
-
Peanut Clusters (0.40 lbs.)
Six delicious ounces of peanut butter and chocolate covered peanut clusters.
$5.95
-
Zippy's Almond & Apricot Bar (1.4 Ounces - 0.09 lbs.)
In honor of our furry friend that visits the shop at cape may peanut butter Co., we proudly present zippy's nut bar. A great blend of puffed rice, oats, almonds, dried apricots, CMPBC peanut butter, butter, sugar, honey, salt, and vanilla.
$2.99
-
Zippy's Nut Bar with Cranberries (1.4 Ounces - 0.09 lbs.)
In honor of our furry friend that visits the shop at cape may peanut butter Co., we proudly present zippy's nut bar. A great blend of puffed rice, oats, peanuts, cranberries, coconut, CMPBC peanut butter, butter, sugar, molasses, honey, and vanilla.
$2.99
-
Peanut Butter Candy Straws (0.45 lbs.)
$7.95
-

Peanuts & Snacks

You'll love the bertie county peanuts we carry!
Blister Fried Bertie County Peanuts
Blister fried bertie county peanuts. 10 ounces - 0.80 lbs., 30 ounces - 2.00 lbs.
$9.95
-
Weeping Mary's Ghost Pepper Bertie County Peanuts
Weeping mary's ghost pepper bertie county peanuts. 10 ounces - 0.50 lbs., 30 ounces - 1.90 lbs.
$9.95
-
Honey Roasted Bertie County Peanuts (10 Ounces - 0.80 lbs.)
Honey roasted bertie county peanuts.
$9.95
-
Sea Salt & Black Pepper Bertie County Peanuts
Sea salt and black pepper bertie county peanuts. 10 ounces - 0.80 lbs., 30 ounces - 2.00 lbs.
$9.95
-
Virginia Dill Pickle Peanuts (1.00 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Virginia Diner Maple & Bacon Peanuts (1.00 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Virginia Diner Sweet Onion Peanuts (1.00 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Mrs. Miller's Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread (0.85 lbs.)
$6.00
-
Peanut Butter Cookie Dough (1.10 lbs.) (Peanuts & Snacks)
It's here. Peanut butter cookie dough! Eat it, don't bake it!
$9.99
-
Thai Peanut Sauce & Dip (1.10 lbs.)
$8.95
-
Zippy's Almond & Apricot Bar (1.4 Ounces - 0.09 lbs.) (Peanuts & Snacks)
In honor of our furry friend that visits the shop at cape may peanut butter Co., we proudly present zippy's nut bar. A great blend of puffed rice, oats, almonds, dried apricots, CMPBC peanut butter, butter, sugar, honey, salt, and vanilla.
$2.99
-
Zippy's Nut Bar with Cranberries (1.4 Ounces - 0.09 lbs.) (Peanuts & Snacks)
In honor of our furry friend that visits the shop at cape may peanut butter Co., we proudly present zippy's nut bar. A great blend of puffed rice, oats, peanuts, cranberries, coconut, CMPBC peanut butter, butter, sugar, molasses, honey, and vanilla.
$2.99
-
Cape May Curry Peanut Soup Mix (0.50 lbs.)
A hearty blend of peanut flour, vegetables and spices. Just add stock and heat!
$6.99
-
Southern Peanut Soup Mix (0.50 lbs.)
A hearty blend of peanut flour, vegetables and spices. Just add stock, cream and heat!
$6.99
-

Coffee, Tea & Cocoa

Try our delicious flavored flavored coffees and teas by crescent moon.
Cape May Breakfast Blend Coffee - Whole Bean (0.75 lbs.)
Whole bean. Cape may breakfast blend from crescent moon coffee company.
$14.95
-
Cape May Breakfast Blend Ground Coffee (0.75 lbs.)
Cape may breakfast blend from crescent moon coffee company.
$14.95
-
Chocolate Hazelnut Coffee by Crescent Moon (0.75 lbs.)
Chocolate hazelnut coffee by crescent moon.
$14.95
-
Coconut Vanilla Black Tea by Crescent Moon (1.10 lbs.)
$15.75
-
Harvest Tea by Crescent Moon (1.10 lbs.)
$15.75
-
Key West Tea by Crescent Moon (1.10 lbs.)
$15.75
-
Mango Amazon Tea by Crescent Moon (1.10 lbs.)
$15.75
-
Moroccan Mint Tea by Crescent Moon (1.10 lbs.)
Moroccan mint tea by crescent moon.
$15.75
-
Peanut Butter Cup Hot Cocoa (1.00 lbs.)
You'll love our peanut butter cup hot cocoa!
$7.95
-
Snickers Coffee by Crescent Moon (0.75 lbs.)
$14.95
-
Vanilla Hazelnut Coffee by Crescent Moon (0.75 lbs.)
$14.95
-
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Coffee by Crescent Moon (0.75 lbs.)
$14.95
-

Dog Treats

Your dog will love these healthy, homemade treats made with our peanut butter. Plus, a portion of sales goes to support pet based programs!
Good Dog Cookies - Large (8 Ounces - 0.60 lbs.)
Peanut butter dog treat made with our natural PB. (about 25 cookies).
$8.99
-
Good Dog Cookies - Small (5 in a Bag - 0.60 lbs.)
Healthy, homemade peanut butter dog treats.
$3.00
-

Gift Packs

A Cluster of Peanut Butter Delight PB Gift Set (GS2-PB)
This PB gift pack makes a great gift! Your giftee will enjoy our choc choc and natural peanut PB's, Mrs. Miller's strawberry jam, a spreader and a bag of peanut clusters.
$29.99
-
Deluxe Collection of Favorites PB Gift Set (GS4-PB)
This great PB gift pack has honey roast PB, butter scotch PB, choc choc PB, natural peanut PB, Mrs. Miller's dutch apple jam, powdered choc choc PB, powdered natural, PB nonpareils, elki's Thai peanut sauce and dip and a CMPBC spreader!
$59.95
-
The Ultimate Decadent Collection PB Gift Set (GS3-PB)
This great PB gift pack has butter scotch PB, natural peanut PB, powdered butter scotch, powdered natural, PB cup hot cocoa, Mrs. Miller's marshmallow PB spread, a PB cup and a CMPBC spreader!
$39.95
-
Disclaimer: Menu-Prices gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.

Search

Close