Navigation
  1. Home »
  2. Restaurants »
  3. Bagel Jay's Menu Prices

Bagel Jay's Menu Prices

Verified Prices
Menu-Prices is not associated with Bagel Jay's
Jump to Section Show
You are viewing Bagel Jay's prices confirmed by Menu-Prices at one or more locations in United States
Prices shown in: USD

Popular Items

Flavored Shmear (on a Bagel)
$3.39
-
No. 2. Egg, Ham, & Cheese
$4.29
-
Pizza Bagel
$4.49
-
Baker's Dozen Bagel
$11.99
-

Oven Fresh

The way they're supposed to be! Jay's secret recipe - New York style, hearth baked fresh throughout the day! These bagels do not come with toppings - if you are looking for shmears or other toppings please check out the other sections of our menu. DO NOT add requests for these toppings in the special instructions section.
Single Bagel
$1.25
-
Bagel (1/2 Dozen)
$6.75
-
Baker's Dozen Bagel (Oven Fresh)
$11.99
-
Sack of Bagels & More
Baker's dozen with tub of butter and tub of shmear.
$16.99
-
Cinnamon Stick
$2.59
-
Asiago
$1.79
-
Blueberry Muffin
$2.19
-
Pastry Heart
$2.59
-
Cinnamon Twist
$2.59
-
Oatmeal
$1.60
-
Yogurt Parfait
$3.99
-

Shmears

It doesn't come any better than this! Our spreads are made with the freshest cream cheese available. You'll find plenty of hand-chopped vegetables, pure honey, strawberries, and smoked salmon.
Plain Shmear (on a Bagel)
$2.89
-
Plain Lite Shmear (on a Bagel)
$2.89
-
Flavored Shmear (on a Bagel) (Shmears)
$3.39
-
Lox Shmear (on a Bagel)
$3.89
-
Tub of Plain Shmear
$3.19
-
Tub of Plain Lite Shmear
$3.19
-
Tub of Flavored Shmear
$4.49
-
Tub of Lox Shmear
$5.19
-
Bagel with Butter
$2.09
-
Bagel with Jelly
$1.79
-
Bagel with Smart Balance
$2.09
-
Bagel with PB&J
$3.09
-
Muffin with Butter
$2.89
-

Eggel Bagels

Farm fresh favorites - all day long!
No. 1. Egg & Cheese
$3.29
-
No. 2. Egg, Ham, & Cheese (Eggel Bagels)
$4.29
-
No. 3. Egg, Bacon, & Cheese
$4.29
-
No. 4. Egg, Chicken Sausage, & Cheese
$4.29
-

Deli Favorites

Any deli sandwich made on your choice of bagel or wheat wrap, with your choice of lettuce, tomato, cukes, red onion, hot banana peppers and alfalfa sprouts.
Roasted Turkey Breast
$6.15
-
Ham
$6.15
-
Roast Beef
$6.95
-
Corned Beef
$6.95
-
BLT
Served with Mayo.
$5.19
-

Jay's Classics

Available on your choice of bagel, or wheat wrap.
Tuna Salad
$6.15
-
Tuna Melt
$6.75
-
Chicken Salad
$6.75
-
Egg Salad
$6.15
-
Cheese Melt
$2.79
-
Pizza Bagel (Jay's Classics)
$4.49
-
Veggie Delight
Lettuce, tomato, cukes, red onion, alfalfa sprouts, deli mustard.
$4.59
-
Hummus
$5.59
-

Taste Tempting Specialties

The Delaware
Roasted turkey, swiss cheese, coleslaw, and Russian dressing.
$7.49
-
The Buffalo Club
Roasted turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
$7.49
-
Albuquerque Turkey
Roasted turkey, a shmear of red pepper jalapeño, lettuce, and tomato.
$7.49
-
Athens Turkey
Turkey breast, hummus with feta, lettuce, tomato, and special dressing.
$7.49
-
Mediterranean Tuna Spectacular
Our classic tuna, provolone cheese, sliced black olives, special dressing, lettuce, and tomato.
$7.49
-
Hummus Wrap Spectacular
Hummus, feta, black olives, red onion, and special dressing.
$7.49
-
The Snyder
Sahlen's ham with scallion shmear, lettuce, and tomato.
$7.49
-
The Reuben
Hot corned beef or roasted turkey, melted swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing.
$7.99
-
The Hopkins
Hot corned beef, swiss cheese, coleslaw, and Russian dressing.
$7.99
-
The Downtowner
Rare roast beef, red onion, hot banana peppers, and a shmear of garlic and herb.
$7.99
-
Athens Chicken
Marinated chicken, hummus with feta, lettuce, tomato, and special dressing.
$7.99
-
Chicken Club Wrap
Wheat wrap with marinated chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato on ranch dressing.
$7.99
-
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Marinated chicken breast, Asiago cheese, lettuce, tomato, and caesar dressing.
$7.99
-
The Hertel
Turkey, ham, pepperoni, melted provolone, tomato, banana pepper, and special dressing on a toasted focaccia.
$7.99
-

Salads

White Fish Salad
$7.99
-
Cream Cheese & Nova
Lettuce, tomato, cukes, red onion, and capers. And a bagel choice.
$8.49
-
Greek Salad
$5.19
-
Caesar Salad
$5.19
-
Green Salad with Tuna
$6.99
-
Chicken Caesar Salad
$6.99
-
Classic Salad Plate
Choice of two scoops of our classic salads - tuna, egg, or chicken, with lettuce, tomato, cukes, and bagel chips.
$7.79
-

Soup of the Day

Soup (Regular) - Chicken Noodle
$2.49
-
Soup (Large) - Chicken Noodle
$3.19
-
Chili-Regular
In season.
$3.79
-
Chili-Large
In season.
$4.79
-

Side Orders

Chips
$1.29
-
Pretzels
$1.29
-
Potato Salad
$1.75
-
Coleslaw
$1.75
-

Desserts

Cookie
$1.85
-
Chocolate Covered Macaroon
$1.85
-
Brownie
$2.69
-
Crumb Cake
$2.69
-
Pound Cake
$2.69
-
Black & White Cookie
$2.69
-

Beverages

Jakee's Java
Our finest dark roast.
$2.09
-
Pepsi Products (Can)
$2.09
-
Iced Coffee
$2.99
-
Hot Chocolate
$2.09
-
Hot Tea
$2.09
-
Cappuccino
$2.79
-
French Vanilla
$2.79
-
Original
$2.69
-
Lipton Tea
$2.69
-
Dr. Brown's (cans)
$2.69
-
Tropicana Juice
$2.69
-
Milk
$1.50
-
Gatorade
$2.69
-
Aquafina Water
$1.70
-

Java to Go Box

Java to Go Box
Includes cream, sugar, stirrers, and cups.
$16.99
-
Disclaimer: Menu-Prices gathers actual pricing information from sources such as on-site visits, business websites, and phone interviews. The prices reported on this webpage derive from one or more of those sources. Naturally, the prices reported on this website may not be current, and may not apply to all locations of a given business brand. To obtain current pricing, contact the individual business location of interest to you.

Search

Close